← All games

02 / PROJECT STORY · DESIGNER DIARY

JukeBox

Choose an illustration for the music and explain the connection. Find the player who had to use an assigned card.

Play JukeBox

01Inspiration

Years ago, a friend and I discussed Debussy's Clair de lune and Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata: which sounded more like moonlight? She chose Debussy, because “Beethoven sounds like someone banging on your door in the middle of the night.” When I listened to Beethoven, though, I pictured someone standing by a railing at night, silently watching moonlight flow like still water.

The same piece of music can bring completely different images to mind. I wanted to make a game out of that exchange: choose a picture, explain why the music made you think of it, and hear how others understood it.

In JukeBox, players listen to music, choose illustrations, and explain the connection. Most can choose their cards freely. One person must use an assigned card without letting the others find out.

Physical prototype
Physical prototype
Cards, theater board, and player pieces. A phone plays the music.

02Early roles and win conditions

The earliest prototype had five players: an Author, a Spy, and three Civilians. Each held five illustrated cards. The Author and Civilians formed a team against the Spy.

Everyone first listened to three pieces of music. The Author secretly selected the target piece and an illustration. The Spy learned the target before choosing a card; the Civilians chose without knowing it. Once everyone had chosen, the target music was revealed, followed by the cards and explanations. Players then guessed each other's roles.

The Author and Spy could choose a picture to fit the music, while the Civilians had to find a connection for a card they had already chosen. I hoped that difference would lead to interesting explanations, but the win conditions were difficult to resolve.

I listed the possible outcomes of a round. A Civilian could vote for the Author, the Spy, or another Civilian: three possibilities. The Spy could identify the Author correctly or incorrectly: two possibilities. Together they formed six cells. If each cell could award victory to either the Author's team or the Spy, there were 2⁶, or 64, possible arrangements. I compared different allocations and considered draws, trying to give every role a reason to participate seriously.

One version allowed the Author's team to win if the Civilians voted for either the Author or another Civilian, provided the Spy guessed the Author incorrectly. The diagram marks those two outcomes.

Working through the old win conditions
Working through the old win conditions
Both marked outcomes award victory to the Author's team, so Civilians could win without recognizing the Author.

This meant the Author could deliberately choose a less fitting picture to look like a Civilian. The Civilians did not need to recognize the Author either: as long as they avoided voting for the Spy and the Spy guessed wrong, their team still won. I found this loophole while working through the rules. The win conditions were encouraging vague explanations.

The Author also faced conflicting incentives. They wanted the Civilians to recognize them, but the Spy heard the same explanation. A clearer clue could help teammates and the opponent at the same time.

03Simplifying roles and scoring

I first tried moving from team victories to individual points. In one version, the Author scored by being recognized by Civilians and identifying the Spy. The Spy tried to be mistaken for the Author while avoiding the Author's suspicion. Civilians could also score by improvising explanations that made the Author believe they had known the target beforehand.

Individual scoring made it easier to adjust each role's rewards, but added more conditions to remember. In some versions, the Civilians and Spy were both pretending to be the Author, making those two roles increasingly similar to play.

My original reason for making the game was to hear someone explain the image they heard in the music. I did not want complicated roles and scoring to take up too much attention. I decided to simplify, removing the Author and the choice of three target pieces so the rules could focus on choosing cards and explaining them.

Now each round uses one piece of music, known to everyone. Most players choose freely from five cards. Only the secret Improviser must play an assigned card. After hearing the explanations, everyone tries to identify the person who had no choice.

Rules before and after simplification
Rules before and after simplification
Removing the target piece and Author role means everyone hears the same music. Only the Improviser cannot choose a card freely.

In the basic scoring rules, listeners advance two spaces for a correct accusation. The Improviser advances three spaces if no more than half the listeners identify them; a tie counts as a success. Everyone races around a theater board. The game supports 3–8 players.

I kept the Improviser because an assigned card prompts players to try pictures they would not normally choose. The others also have a reason to listen carefully to the explanation as they try to identify the role.

04The length of the music

During an in-person playtest, the group spent a lot of time listening and much less choosing cards, explaining them, and making judgments. I shortened the excerpts to 10–15 seconds and gave players their cards before playback, so they could look at them while listening.

Shortening the excerpts meant choosing the musical phrases again. Some pieces establish their character quickly; others needed a different starting point to avoid playing only an introduction. The library contains 30 short excerpts, which can be replayed. The tabletop version needs only one device for playback. Everything else uses physical cards and a board.

05Music and artwork

Several testers suggested adding rock or pop music, or switching to an anime art style, to reach a wider audience. I brought up the 18xx board games: their railway and stock-market rules are complex and their artwork is plain, yet they have an audience that enjoys them. I felt JukeBox could keep the material I preferred rather than replace classical music because its audience was smaller.

I tried different directions. Lyrics tended to draw associations toward the literal meaning of the words, while a mix of art styles made the cards feel inconsistent together. I kept the combination of classical music and Renaissance painting. The style of the 65 illustrations draws on the work of Piero della Francesca.

The pictures need distinct actions, emotions, and relationships. If a picture fits almost any piece of music, choosing it requires very little thought. I also left room for different interpretations: someone waiting alone, for instance, might suggest loneliness or peace.

Solitary scene
Solitary scene
Street scene
Street scene
Two example cards: one depicts solitude, the other a group activity.

06Different interpretations in play

In an early five-player test, one person's choices puzzled the other four. Moonlight, for example, made him think of soldiers. I initially worried that associations so different from everyone else's would reduce role identification to random guessing.

After a few rounds, the others became familiar with how he chose and explained his cards, and could use that to judge his role. He had not changed his associations, and we did not necessarily agree with his explanations, but we could recognize patterns across rounds.

We still interpret music differently, but we can nevertheless develop a considerable understanding of one another. That was the inspiration for this game and what I wanted to make possible through its design.

Next projectMade With Care